
JAKARTA — Political and social observer Inas N Zubir has raised concerns over the Constitutional Court’s (MK) reasoning in Case Decision No. 01/PHPU.PRES-XXIV/2026 concerning Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s educational qualifications.
The former member of Indonesia’s House of Representatives (DPR RI) argued that the Court’s statement that it had not found documents proving Gibran’s completion of overseas education equivalent to senior high school should not automatically be interpreted as a conclusion that Gibran does not possess the required diploma or graduation documents.
In his article entitled “The Constitutional Court Dares Not Say That Gibran Does Not Have a High School-Equivalent Diploma,” Inas questioned the evidentiary process conducted during the proceedings, particularly the efforts to trace Gibran’s primary educational records.
According to Inas, the Court stated that, after examining all evidence submitted by the parties and the facts revealed during the hearings, it had not found any diploma, certificate, or other document demonstrating that Gibran had completed overseas education equivalent to senior high school or its equivalent.
These requirements relate to the educational qualifications for presidential and vice-presidential candidates, as stipulated in Articles 169(r) and 227(l) of Indonesia’s Election Law.
Questions Raised Over the Search for Primary Documents
Inas argued that a key issue requiring clarification is how the search for these documents was conducted and which parties the Court approached for information.
He noted that the proceedings involved, among others, the Directorate General of Primary and Secondary Education, the General Elections Commission (KPU), and education attachés at the Indonesian embassies in Australia and Singapore.
However, Inas believes that certain aspects of the evidentiary process warrant further scrutiny.
In his view, primary documents concerning educational history and graduation should have been traced directly through the individual concerned and the educational institutions that issued them, including UTS Insearch/UTS College and the Management Development Institute of Singapore (MDIS).
He questioned why these institutions were not approached directly to verify the relevant educational records during the process in question.
For Inas, this question is important because the absence of documents from the court record does not, by itself, prove that those documents never existed.
Distinguishing Between Failure to Find Evidence and a Finding That Documents Do Not Exist
Inas emphasized that there is a distinction between a court stating that it did not find certain documents during proceedings and reaching a legal conclusion that an individual does not possess the required documents.
He argued that the Court’s reasoning should be read carefully to avoid conclusions that go beyond what the ruling actually states.
He also maintained that the Constitutional Court did not explicitly conclude that Gibran lacked educational documents equivalent to a senior high school diploma. In Inas’s interpretation, the Court instead left the substantive question of whether the educational requirements had been validly satisfied to other institutions authorized to address the matter under the applicable legal framework.
On that basis, Inas argued that the ruling should not be used to claim that the Constitutional Court had definitively established that Gibran did not possess a high school-equivalent diploma.
“The Court only dares to say, ‘We did not find it on the hearing table,’” Inas wrote at the conclusion of his article.



