Inas N Zubir: Rocky Gerung Accused of Crossing Ethical Boundaries of the Presidential Advisory Council

JAKARTA — A statement by Rocky Gerung, a member of Indonesia’s Presidential Advisory Council (Wantimpres), suggesting that Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka should resign has drawn scrutiny. Gerung is accused of crossing institutional ethical boundaries by expressing political views in public, despite legal provisions governing the confidentiality of advice and recommendations provided to the President.
The assessment was made by Inas N Zubir, who highlighted Gerung’s remarks during the Akbar Faizal Uncensored podcast, which aired around October 8–9, 2026, just days after Gerung was inaugurated as a member of Wantimpres on October 2, 2026.
During the podcast, Gerung suggested that Gibran should resign gracefully or demonstrate statesmanship. According to Gerung, such a move could ease public tensions that might escalate into mass unrest, prevent President Prabowo Subianto from being drawn into the controversy, and respond to a Constitutional Court ruling concerning candidacy requirements.
Gerung also emphasized that his remarks represented his personal views and did not constitute an official position of Wantimpres.
However, Inas argued that this clarification did not automatically separate Gerung’s public statements from the office he had recently assumed. As a public official serving within the President’s advisory institution, Gerung remains subject to legal and institutional ethical constraints, she argued.
Article 6 of the Wantimpres Law Under Scrutiny
Inas referred to Article 6, Paragraph (1), of Law No. 19 of 2006 concerning the Presidential Advisory Council. The provision states:
“Members of the Presidential Advisory Council are not permitted, in carrying out their duties and functions, to provide information or statements and/or disseminate the contents of advice and recommendations to any party.”
According to Inas, this provision underscores that advice and recommendations to the President should be delivered through internal channels rather than disclosed publicly.
She argued that when a Wantimpres member publicly puts forward a political recommendation concerning the position of the Vice President, questions arise over the boundaries between personal opinion and institutional responsibility.
Inas also noted that Mahfud MD had previously highlighted a similar provision, particularly the restriction on Wantimpres members publicly disclosing matters related to their duties and the advice they provide to the President.
Remarks Considered a Potential Threat to Government Cohesion
Beyond legal and institutional ethical concerns, Inas argued that the proposal for Gibran to resign could potentially affect the cohesion of the Prabowo–Gibran administration.
According to her, the President and Vice President were elected together through the electoral process. Calls for either of them to leave the administration could therefore weaken the unity of leadership entrusted with a public mandate.
Inas emphasized that Wantimpres is tasked with providing advice and recommendations to the President, whether requested or unsolicited. The institution, she argued, is not intended to serve as a platform for public political statements that could heighten tensions or cast doubt on the legitimacy of the country’s elected leadership.
She maintained that publicly delivering such recommendations runs counter to the principles of confidentiality and internal consultation that form part of Wantimpres’ institutional responsibilities.



