Petitioner Asks Indonesia’s Constitutional Court to Recognize University Degrees as Proof of Education for Presidential and Vice-Presidential Candidates

JAKARTA — Indonesia’s Constitutional Court (MK) is being asked to review the educational requirements for presidential and vice-presidential candidates. An Indonesian citizen, Farhan Hilmy, has challenged provisions requiring proof of completion of secondary education as an administrative document for registering presidential and vice-presidential tickets.
In his petition, Farhan asks the Court to allow diplomas or graduation certificates from higher education institutions, ranging from bachelor’s (S-1) and master’s (S-2) degrees to doctoral (S-3) degrees, to serve as substitutes for a senior high school diploma or its equivalent, provided the qualifications are valid and recognized by the state.
According to the Court’s official website, the petitioner argues that the current regulations place excessive emphasis on administrative formalities and fail to accommodate candidates who have completed higher levels of education.
He contends that rejecting a valid university diploma as proof of educational attainment could create legal uncertainty and undermine substantive justice.
Alleged Inconsistency Between Legal Provisions
The petition challenges the relationship between Article 169(r) and Article 227(l) of Law No. 7 of 2017 on General Elections.
Article 169(r) stipulates that presidential and vice-presidential candidates must have completed at least senior high school, an Islamic senior high school (madrasah aliyah), a vocational high school, or an equivalent level of education.
Meanwhile, Article 227(l) establishes an administrative requirement for candidates to submit a certificate issued by a secondary education institution or program as proof that they meet the educational criteria.
According to the petitioner, this administrative provision does not provide an alternative for candidates to use higher education credentials, even when they have completed a more advanced level of education.
He argues that the restriction could create difficulties for candidates with advanced academic qualifications or those who have pursued accelerated international education pathways.
Legal Argument Based on Higher Educational Attainment
In his petition, Farhan invokes the legal principle of argumentum a fortiori, a form of reasoning in which an argument is considered even stronger when applied to a more compelling case.
On this basis, he argues that individuals who have legitimately completed bachelor’s, master’s, or doctoral degrees recognized by the state should be considered to have met the minimum educational requirement.
The petitioner also links the issue to citizens’ constitutional right to equal opportunities in government and the principle of fair elections.
He maintains that restricting acceptable documentation to proof of secondary education could create unnecessary administrative barriers for prospective candidates. It could also affect the public’s interest in a national leadership selection process based on competence and merit.
Petitioner Seeks a New Interpretation of Article 227
The judicial review petition has been registered with the Constitutional Court under Case No. 382/PUU-XXIV/2026.
In his formal request, the petitioner asks the Court to grant the petition in full and declare the phrase “by a secondary education institution or program” in Article 227(l) of the Election Law conditionally unconstitutional and without binding legal force under certain circumstances.
He asks the Court to interpret the provision as also covering higher education institutions or the ministry responsible for higher education, allowing prospective candidates with valid university qualifications to use their higher education credentials as proof of educational attainment.



